Electionem per revelationem: Truth, charisma, and the exhaustion of discernment in post-totalitarian modernity

by Andrees-Cosmina Preda, Radu Preda,

Recent presidential elections in Romania reveal not only institutional and political tensions, but a deeper anthropological and epistemological crisis: the erosion of discernment as a condition of freedom. Electoral choice, traditionally understood as a rational act of deliberation, increasingly functions as a form of affective recognition, borrowing symbolic legitimacy from religious language rather than from argument and knowledge. We propose a social-theological and epistemological analysis of this phenomenon, structured around five interconnected dimensions: the post-totalitarian fragility of freedom and the delegation of judgment; the absolutization of political charisma and the logic of false recognition; the role of digital technologies in accelerating post-rationality and cognitive fatigue; the illicit symbolic transfer between religion and politics; and, finally, an anthropological diagnosis of the post-totalitarian mind, marked by the loss of epistemic humility. Our central argument is that contemporary political dysfunction cannot be explained solely by manipulation or institutional failure, but by the weakening of the subject’s capacity to know. Where truth is reduced to affective intensity or sacralized authority, freedom survives only as procedure, not as lived responsibility.

(DOI: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.18732963)

published in Vol. 25 - No. 2 - Winter 2025

  Site Meter

Indexed in:

  • Social Sciences Citation Index
    (ISI Thomson Reuters)
  • IPSA
  • GESIS
  • CIAONET
  • EBSCO
  • CEEOL
  • EPNET

International
Advisory Board

  • Alina Mungiu-Pippidi (chair) Hertie School of Governance
  • Larry Diamond Stanford University
  • Tom Gallagher University of Bradford
  • Alena Ledeneva University College London
  • Michael McFaul Stanford University
  • Dennis Deletant Georgetown University
  • Helen Wallace London School of Economics and Political Science

Editorial Board

  • Claudiu Tufiș
  • Bogdan Iancu
  • George Jiglau
  • Ingi Iusmen
  • Gabriel Bădescu
  • Andrei Macsut
  • Laura Voinea

Published by:

Societatea Academica Romana