Paper
Normalizing Mercenarism as Business: The Process of Regulating Private Military and Security Companies at the United Nations Level
by Ruxandra Ivan, Ruxandra Ivan, Ruxandra Ivan,
This article examines efforts to regulate private military and security companies (PMSCs) in different UN fora since 2005, in order to understand the processes that led to a significant dilution of initial regulatory ambitions. The analysis of the proceedings of the three working groups relevant to this process suggests a decreasing level of ambition concerning the creation of a binding international instrument that would ensure the compliance of PMSCs with international human rights standards and international humanitarian law. This article argues that the dilution of strong arguments in favor of binding regulation can be attributed to three types of factors: the shifting of the debate from experts and activists to state representatives; the existence of a North-South cleavage on the issue at the intergovernmental level; and the emergence of competing regulatory fora such as private governance by the industry itself (the International Code of Conduct Association) and the Swiss-led initiative for the creation of a soft law instrument (the Montreux Document). Thus, despite an initial general consensus on the threat that unregulated PMSCs pose to human rights, the structure of the regulation process led to a diluted outcome wherein human rights issues were relegated behind the interests of both hegemonic states and the industry.
published in Vol. 23 - No. 1 - Summer 2023
|
ABSTRACT
This issue includes a collection of four articles. Ruxandra Ivan’s article offers a detailed analysis of the decline in regulatory ambitions for private military and security companies (PMSCs) in UN discussions over the last two decades. The author explains how the shift in debate from experts to state representatives, geopolitical divides, and competing regulatory approaches... »
PAPERS
The European Union and its Member States are currently facing an unprecedented migration phenomenon, a refugee crisis in Ukraine triggered by the Russian Federation’s military invasion of Ukraine that began in February 2022. This ongoing military conflict has created the biggest humanitarian crisis in modern European history, resulting in many casualties and population movements outside... »
Grassroots cadres are managers responsible for grassroots governance and serve as the final interpreters and executors of central government policies. They play a critical role in policy implementation, particularly in the “last mile” of the process. However, despite the government’s efforts to implement public policies, corruption among grassroots cadres in the field of people’s livelihoods... »
This article studies the relationship between the degree of populist or pluralist rhetoric employed by governments, and how it affects the perception of anticorruption effectiveness from its citizens. By combining data from the 2021 Global Corruption Barometer survey and from the 2020 Global Party Survey, a consolidated dataset is created, including information on the degree... »
This article examines efforts to regulate private military and security companies (PMSCs) in different UN fora since 2005, in order to understand the processes that led to a significant dilution of initial regulatory ambitions. The analysis of the proceedings of the three working groups relevant to this process suggests a decreasing level of ambition concerning... »
|